It was a big weekend for St Andrews University.
As a new academic year began, The Times and Sunday Times Good University Guide named St Andrews the best university in Britain.
Ahead of Oxford. Ahead of Cambridge.
Ancient. Prestigious. Rarefied. The kind of place where, I suspect, even the seagulls sound privately educated.
However, more interestingly (well, for me anyway), just one page over was another story about St Andrews.
The arrival of Wetherspoons.
‘The Red Gown’. A brand-new Spoons. In the student halls of St Andrews.
Oh, the glorious collision of it all!
One of Britain's oldest, grandest and most exclusive seats of learning meets the pub chain much of polite marketing society has long turned its nose up at.
Newton's Third Law tells us that for every action there is an equal and opposite reaction.
I appreciate St Andrews opening a Wetherspoons isn't quite what he had in mind.
But there is something wonderfully countercultural about the rise and rise of Spoons right now.
Because the more our lives become digital, automated, personalised and increasingly artificial, the more valuable places that are gloriously, messily, indiscriminately human begin to feel.
I've always liked Wetherspoons.
And I don't mean in that slightly ironic, anthropological way that some of my Soho House-going, Pelican-eating, mezcal-Negroni-drinking friends might find socially acceptable.
I like the food (Don’t knock it til you’ve tried it). I like the Guinness. I even kind of like the carpets.
But mostly, I like the people and how easy it is to feel at home here.
No judgement. No pretence. No need to be anything other than yourself.
The beer may be cheap but the insight is rich.
A couple of years ago, The Times journalist Harry Wallop did something every planner should occasionally do.
He spent 24 hours in a Wetherspoons.
Not commissioned a study about one. Not scraped the social conversation around one. Not asked a machine to synthesise the prevailing attitudes towards one.
He sat in one.
And watched Britain wander through the doors.
Breakfasts and bottomless coffees. Older people. Workers. Students. Friends. People eating alone. People meeting others.
Different ages. Different incomes. Different lives. Different reasons for being there.
Different people. Different needs. Same place.
And perhaps that's the real genius of Spoons.
For all the lazy caricatures, Wetherspoons has quietly created something our fragmented society desperately needs.
A members' club with no membership.
No velvet rope. No dress code. No cultural qualification.
You just walk in.
And belong.
Which, of course, is what pubs and community centres have always done at their best: brought people together when they most needed somewhere to belong. Wetherspoons hasn't reinvented that role. It has simply understood how important it still is.
Years ago, a mentor of mine divided strategists into two camps.
Google Strategists and Real-Life Strategists
He championed unlimited annual leave, provided some of it was spent out in the world.
Museums. Shopping centres. Bingo halls. School gates.
Watching. Listening. Wondering.
I think about him increasingly as our industry rushes to embrace AI.
Because while we talk excitedly about AI allowing us to outsource more and more of the work, I wonder whether we're inadvertently beginning to outsource something rather more precious.
Our curiosity.
Why wonder when we can ask?
Why watch when we can analyse?
Why listen when we can synthesise?
Why spend an afternoon in a shopping centre, a bingo hall or, heaven forbid, a Wetherspoons when we can have dozens of beautifully articulated observations before we've finished our first coffee?
The outsourcing of curiosity.
Perhaps that's the danger we should be talking about.
Not AI replacing strategists. Not AI replacing creatives. Not even AI replacing jobs.
But AI slowly replacing the instinct to go and find things out for ourselves.
Harry didn't spend 24 hours in Wetherspoons because he knew what he'd discover.
He went because he didn't.
AI will undoubtedly allow us to know more about people than at any point in history.
But knowing about people and understanding people aren't quite the same thing.
And in a world where AI is levelling up everyone's ability to create more and more content, fresh human insight and original execution don't become less important.
They become the difference.
So perhaps The Book of ’Spoons really offers our industry just one lesson.
When answers become effortless, curiosity becomes priceless.
So by all means prompt. Search. Synthesise. Analyse.
But every now and again, close the laptop.
Go to the museum. The shopping centre. The school gate (maybe not). The bingo hall.
Or even Spoons.
Sit down. Look around. Listen.
Have a pint.
Maybe have another.
Call it research.
No surprise, I suspect, where I'm writing this.
Author - Tony Quinn, Chief Strategy Officer

